Can we use plastic straws again? What could happen after court quashes Liberal ban

Recent ruling notes it was ‘unreasonable and unconstitutional’ to list all plastic manufactured products as harmful, and that the government acted outside of its authority

Article content

A Federal Court judge has ruled that Ottawa went too far in characterizing all plastic items as toxic in the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA). But don’t expect the sudden return of plastic straws.

When Bill S-5 became law in June after receiving royal assent, it amended the Canadian Environmental Protection Act and gave the federal government the right to regulate the import, manufacture and sale of plastic items, which it promptly did.

Advertisement 2

Article content

Article content

In fact, it had already started. As of last December, regulations banned the manufacture or import of five types of single-use plastics — straws, grocery bags, cutlery, takeout containers and stir sticks. In another month, on Dec. 20, sale of these items is also prohibited. (A sixth type, six-pack ring carriers, are on a similar but slightly delayed timeline of prohibition.)

Thursday’s ruling by Justice Angela Furlanetto notes that it was “unreasonable and unconstitutional” to list all plastic manufactured products as harmful, and that the government acted outside of its authority. “There is no reasonable apprehension” that all listed plastic manufactured items are harmful, she wrote.

But Stewart Elgie, a law professor and director of the Environment Institute at the University of Ottawa, said the decision is unlikely to bring back straws, stir sticks and the like.

“The federal government still has ample authority to regulate plastics that are harmful to the environment,” he said. “They just have to do it in a targeted way, and have the proper scientific support behind it.”

Advertisement 3

Article content

The government, he said, may need to deliver additional, more specific scientific proof that particular plastics and products are harmful to the environment, which could happen in as little as a few months.

In the meantime, he said, “they can go to the court and ask for this judgment to be suspended temporarily until there’s an appeal decision. That’s quite common in court decisions.”

Alternately, “they can bring in an interim order under CEPA that essentially deals with the plastics they’re regulating. And it will regulate them on an interim basis until a permanent regulation is redone.”

Related Stories

The case against the government was brought forward by the Responsible Plastics Use Coalition (RPUC), a not-for-profit corporation comprising companies from the plastics industry who do business in Canada, as well Dow Chemical Canada, Nova Chemicals Corporation and Imperial Oil.

A press release issued yesterday by the RPUC said it supported the federal court decision, adding: “We are currently analyzing court documents and will be considering our next steps upon completing that review.”

Advertisement 4

Article content

But Usman Valiante, a fellow at the Ottawa-based Smart Prosperity Institute, says the industry is unlikely to move quickly on the decision.

“I think, practically, industry is going to wait and see what the government does before anybody starts to try to reintroduce any of this stuff into the market,” he said. “Everybody was anticipating that they wouldn’t be selling this stuff by Dec. 20 and it’s not like they’re going to rush out to start supplying it again, given the uncertainty of where public policy might go.”

“In reality, the decision isn’t that big of a deal,” Elgie adds. “It shouldn’t affect (the government’s) regulation of plastics. I think the industry did it kind of as a shot across the bow. To make sure that the government is careful and thorough about which plastics they regulate (in the future). I don’t think the industry likes having all their products labelled as toxic, and I don’t blame them.”

Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our newsletters here.

Article content


Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.